These two eyeshadows looked similar in texture and function at first glance, so I decided to pick them up. They are not really expensive; they come from the drugstore so why not trying them, right?
Price: 6,29€ for Astor eyeshadow and 2,95€ for Essence duo eyeshadow (in Austria) or 2,99€ in Slovak drugstore.
Colours:
Astor: on the Astor website there are 24 shades available, I’ve seen in Bipa (Austria) only few. I bought shade 810 Treasure Gold which is shimmery light tan colour.
Essence: there are 9 duos on offer so technically 18 shades. I bought duo 03 Irresistible choco cupcake which is combination of shimmery beige and slightly shimmery warm brown.
Texture:
Astor: the brand claims on its website that the eyeshadows have super soft texture. I don’t agree at all. I had to really dig the brush into the product to get something on my brush. The eyeshadow was hard and dry to the touch.
Essence: the eyeshadows are not super soft but softer than the Astor’s one. They are not extremely powdery and apply easily.
|
Duo eyeshadows 03 Irresistible choco cupcake by Essence used dry (left) and wet (right) |
Pigmentation:
When used dry:
Astor: it says on the website that the eyeshadows are highly pigmented. Well, the one I have doesn’t have much of the pigmentation. I had to reapply it few times to get some colour on my lid.
Essence: the eyeshadows have quite a good pigmentation considering that they are from a drugstore. They looked good on the eyes even when used dry.
|
Eyeshadow 810 Treasure Gold by Astor used wet (left) and dry (right) |
When used wet (I used fix spray not water):
Astor: while the eyeshadow has poor pigmentation when dry once you use it with a wet brush the pigmentation becomes a lot more intensive and the eyeshadow actually looks very nice on the eyes.
Essence: since the eyeshadows are quite pigmented when dry I haven’t noticed any significant difference in pigmentation when using them wet.
|
Eyeshadow duo in 03 Irresistible choco cupcake by Essence (used dry) |
Longevity: with good primer both eyeshadows lasted all day. BUT I also noticed that applying wet eyeshadow (in both cases) on cream eyeshadows doesn’t work at all. You will get a strange mixture that doesn’t want to set, therefore use them either wet alone or dry with cream eyeshadows.
|
Eyeshadow 810 Treasure Gold by Astor (used wet) |
Final verdict: I prefer Essence duo eyeshadows since the pigmentation is better in dry conditions. I don’t always have time to wet the brush so pigmented eyeshadow without extra work is important to me. Moreover the price for duo eyeshadow by Essence is far better deal than price for single eyeshadow by Astor.